Selling a junk car in Indiana takes exactly two documents: the Indiana certificate of title, signed by every owner listed on it, and a valid photo ID that matches the name on that title. That’s the whole legal requirement. Keys, registration, and a bill of sale all help — but junk car paperwork in Indiana really comes down to those two items.
Last updated: September 2026
At Cash Car Heroes, we buy junk cars across Indianapolis and Central Indiana every single day, and the paperwork is almost never the hard part. Most sellers spend more time finding a pen than filling anything out. But the occasional sale with a wrinkle — a lost title, a co-owner who moved to Florida, a loan that was paid off in 2015 — can stall for weeks if you don’t know what the Indiana BMV actually wants.
So here’s the checklist. Screenshot it, print it, stick it on the fridge. Then we’ll walk through each item, and what to do when your situation doesn’t fit the tidy version.
The Indiana Junk Car Paperwork Checklist
Required — the sale can’t happen without these:
- Indiana vehicle title, signed by all owners listed on it
- Valid photo ID (driver’s license, state ID, or passport) matching the name on the title
Good to have — not required, but they make the sale smoother:
- Keys — most buyers want them, though a junk car can often sell without them
- Vehicle registration — backs up your ownership if any question comes up
- Lien release — only if a paid-off loan still shows on the title
- Maintenance records — worth mentioning if they show recent work like new tires or a rebuilt transmission
- A bill of sale — your receipt, not a legal requirement (more on this below)
That’s it. No notary, no BMV appointment, no fees. The seller’s side of an Indiana junk car sale is one signed document and the ID to prove you’re the person signing it.
Why the Title Is the One Document That Matters
Indiana is a title state. Ownership of a car transfers when the seller signs the certificate of title over to the buyer — and the BMV instructs sellers to complete the seller and purchaser sections on the title in their entirety (Indiana BMV, 2026). No signed title, no legal transfer. Everything else on the checklist is supporting cast.
Signing it right takes about a minute:
- Flip the title over to the seller’s assignment section.
- Sign and print your name there — and if the title lists more than one owner, every owner signs and prints (Indiana BMV, 2026).
- Complete the odometer statement, the date of sale, and the purchase price.
- Fill in the purchaser information section too. That one surprises people — in Indiana completing the buyer’s information is the seller’s job, not the buyer’s (Indiana BMV, 2026).
One honest warning from experience: don’t sign the title ahead of time “to save a step.” A signed-but-blank title floating around is how ownership disputes start. Sign it when the driver is standing in your driveway with your money.
Lost the title? Fixable, and cheaper than most people expect. Indiana issues duplicates for $15 through your myBMV.com account, any BMV branch, or by mail with State Form 205 (Indiana BMV, 2026), and asks you to allow up to 21 calendar days for the new one to arrive (Indiana BMV FAQ, 2026). Our step-by-step duplicate title guide for Indiana walks through the whole thing. And if the title situation is messier than a simple reprint, our no-title junk car guide covers the workarounds — we handle missing-title sales case by case.
Title in hand and ready to sell? Cash Car Heroes pays cash on the spot with free towing, and 86% of sellers who accept our offer have the car picked up the same day. Call or text (317) 538-4824 or get your offer in 10-15 minutes →
Do You Need a Bill of Sale to Sell a Junk Car in Indiana?
Legally? No. Indiana is blunt about this: a bill of sale cannot be used to transfer ownership of any vehicle that requires a certificate of title (Indiana BMV, 2026). The title does the transferring. The bill of sale is just paper.
Our opinion: fill one out anyway. It takes three minutes and it’s your receipt — proof of what you sold, to whom, for how much, and on what date. If a question ever comes up about the car after it leaves your driveway, that one page answers it. Indiana even has an official version, State Form 44237, and the BMV’s list for an acceptable one is the buyer’s name, the vehicle’s year, make, and model, the VIN, and the seller’s signature and address (Indiana BMV, 2026). Add the price and the date and you’re covered.
What About License Plates and Registration?
Two quick rules here, and one of them surprises people:
- Take your plates off before the car leaves. The BMV says the seller should remove the license plate at the time of the transaction (Indiana BMV, 2026). The plate belongs to you, not the car.
- You don’t have to mail the plates back. Indiana doesn’t require plates from sold vehicles to be returned to the BMV — you can transfer them to another vehicle you own (Indiana BMV, 2026). Our guide to what to do after selling your car in Indiana covers the plate decision, the BMV, and the insurance call in order.
Registration is the “nice to have” of this list. You can sell a junk car with expired registration — condition and registration status are separate questions, and we buy plenty of cars that haven’t been road-legal in years. Current registration just gives the buyer one more document confirming the car is yours. After the sale, there are a few loose ends worth tying up too; our guide to what happens to your junk car after you sell it picks up the story from there.
What If Your Situation Is Complicated?
Most sales are one owner, one title, one signature. Here’s the paperwork picture for the four situations that come up most, drawn from the wrinkles we work through with sellers:
| Situation | What You'll Need | How It Usually Goes |
|---|---|---|
| Two names on the title | Signatures from both owners | Every owner listed on the title signs the seller section. If a co-owner lives out of state, the title can be mailed for signature before the sale — plan a few extra days. |
| Owner passed away | Title plus estate documents | If the title names a transfer-on-death beneficiary, that person brings the title and a copy of the death certificate to a BMV branch and retitles it in their name first. With no TOD designation, it runs through the estate — a will, letters of administration, or a small-estate affidavit — and we can tell you what applies before pickup. |
| Old loan still on the title | Lien release from the lender | If you paid off the car but the lien was never cleared, the lender provides a release — the BMV explains the process on its liens page. Usually a phone call and a short wait. |
| Company or fleet vehicle | Title plus signing authority | Someone authorized to sign for the business signs the title. Bring anything showing you're that someone — a business card and company paperwork usually settle it. |
| Out-of-state title | That state's signed title and your ID | We take these case by case. A clean signed title from another state usually works fine; call us first and we'll confirm before the driver rolls. |
Full disclosure: we can’t solve every one of these on the spot. A lien release depends on the lender, and an estate transfer depends on documents only the family can produce. What we can do is tell you in one phone call exactly which papers your situation needs — before you spend a Saturday at a BMV branch you didn’t need to visit. For the bigger legal picture, our Indiana junk car laws and BMV guide covers salvage titles, abandoned vehicles, and the rest.
Not sure what your situation needs? Tell us what's on the title — joint owners, old lien, estate sale — and we'll tell you exactly what paperwork gets it done. Call or text (317) 538-4824 or see how it works →
What Happens With the Paperwork on Pickup Day?
Short version: five minutes of it. Here’s the play-by-play when a Cash Car Heroes driver arrives:
- The driver does a quick walk-around to confirm the car matches what you described.
- You show your photo ID.
- You sign the title over — buyer info, date, price, odometer line, signatures.
- You get paid in cash or check, on the spot, and the car gets towed for free.
That’s the whole ceremony. Nothing for you to file afterward, no BMV trip required to hand the car off. It’s why 86% of the sellers who accept our offer have the car gone the same day, backed by a 4.8-star rating across 1,219+ Google reviews. Want to prep beyond the paperwork? Our pre-sale junk car checklist covers clearing out the glovebox, pulling the plates, and the other five-minute jobs worth doing before the truck shows up.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need the title to sell a junk car in Indiana?
Usually, yes. Indiana transfers vehicle ownership through the signed certificate of title, so most sales require one. If yours is lost, a duplicate costs $15 from the BMV (Indiana BMV, 2026). Some no-title situations still have workarounds — Cash Car Heroes reviews those case by case, so call before assuming you’re stuck.
Can I sell a junk car with just a bill of sale?
No. The Indiana BMV states a bill of sale cannot transfer ownership of any vehicle that requires a title (Indiana BMV, 2026). A bill of sale — State Form 44237 — is still worth completing as your receipt, recording the buyer, price, date, and VIN, but it rides along with the title rather than replacing it.
What documents do I need to sell my junk car in Indiana?
Two: the Indiana certificate of title signed by every owner listed on it, and a valid photo ID matching the name on the title. Keys, current registration, maintenance records, and a lien release (if an old loan shows on the title) are helpful extras, but the title and ID complete the legal transfer.
Do all owners have to sign the title?
Yes — every owner listed on the title signs and prints their name in the seller’s section before the sale (Indiana BMV, 2026). If a co-owner is out of state, mail the title for their signature before scheduling pickup; that adds a few days but keeps the transfer clean. If an owner has died, the estate paperwork comes first, before anyone signs.
Do I need my license plates or registration to sell a junk car?
You need to remove the plates — the BMV says sellers should take them off at the time of the transaction (Indiana BMV, 2026). They’re yours to keep or transfer to another vehicle. Registration isn’t required to sell, and expired registration is no problem; it simply helps confirm ownership if questions come up.
What paperwork should I keep after selling my junk car?
Keep your copy of the bill of sale, a photo of the front and back of the signed title, and your license plates. Those three items prove exactly when the car stopped being your responsibility — useful if a toll, ticket, or towing notice ever arrives for a car you no longer own.
Get Paid, Paperwork and All, This Week
The paperwork for selling a junk car in Indiana is two items long, and you probably have both within twenty feet of you right now. Grab the title, grab your ID, and the rest — the offer, the towing, the cash — is our job.
Ready when you are. Cash Car Heroes buys junk cars across Indianapolis and Central Indiana — free towing, cash on the spot, quotes in 10-15 minutes, 7 days a week from 8am to 8pm. Call or text (317) 538-4824 or start your quote now →
Get Your Cash Offer Now!
Free • No Obligation • Takes 60 Seconds